|
ÔÓ S ÓÔ € ô [ã ò X X ¸ Ôò òÝ ÝÝ ‚ " ÿÿÿ˜2 ÝÝ Ý[Page€490]Ý ƒ " ÿÿ˜2 3 ݌Р#Þ ' ÐŒÔ € X ¸ X ò ô [ã Ôó óÓ S ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ & ÿÿÿ ÝÔ S ô$C!¡$ð ÔÓ S ÓÓ ÓÓ € ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ & ÿÿÿš3 ÝÝ Ýau€sens€du€par.€21(5)€pr cit .Ý ƒ & ÿÿš3 4 ݌Рô$C!( ÐŒÓ ÓÓ € ÓÓ S ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ & ÿÿÿ ÝÔ S ó&B# &ï" ÔÓ S ÓÓ ÓÓ € ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ & ÿÿÿÈ4 ÝÝ ÝLe€savant€juge€de€premi re€instance€a€toutefois€estim ,€et€la€Cour€dð ðappel€a€abond €dans€sonÐ ó&B#* Ðsens,€que€d s€le€d but€lð ðintention€ tait€que€le€ch que€en€cause€ne€soit€pas€encaiss €par€laÐ L(›$, Ðpreneuse,€mais€quð ðau€moyen€dð ðun€faux€astucieux,€il€soit€n goci €de€mani re€ € tre€payableÐ ¥)ô%. Ðau€tireur€lui„m me.€Il€est€ vident€que€la€question€de€savoir€si€la€preneuse€doit€ tre€consid r eÐ þ*M'0 Ðâ âcomme€une€personne€fictive€constitue€le€coeur€m me€de€ce€pourvoi€et,€ €mon€avis,€elle€est€ Ð W,¦(2 Ðtrancher€suivant€le€raisonnement€de€lord€Herschell€dans€lð ðarr t€ò òBank€of€England€v.ó ó€ò òVaglianoÐ ± ÐBrothers,€ó ó[1891]€A.C.€107,€ €la€p.€153,€o €il€dit:Ý ƒ & ÿÿÈ4 L5 ݌РY Ðâ âŒÓ ÓÓ € ÓÓ S ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ ÿÿÿ ÝÔ S X ¶ ÔÓ Ø ÓÓ ÓÓ E 1 ‰ ‰ ‰ a ¹ i Á q É ! y Ñ )" ° œX E ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ ÿÿÿÝ8 ÝÝ Ý[TRADUCTION]€Pour€les€motifs€que€jð ðai€expos s€assez€longuement€ €Vos€Seigneuries,Ð X Ðje€suis€arriv € €la€conclusion€que,€premi rement,€chaque€fois€que€le€nom€inscrit€commeÐ ï > Ðle€nom€du€preneur€nð ðest€quð ðun€simulacre€et€quð ðil€nð ðy€a€aucune€intention€de€payerÐ Õ $ Ðuniquement€le€preneur€nomm ,€celui„ci€est€une€personne€fictive€au€sens€de€la€loi,€peuÐ » Ðimporte€que€le€nom€soit€celui€dð ðune€personne€qui€existe€ou€dð ðune€personne€qui€nð ðexisteÐ ¡ ð Ðpas,€et€deuxi mement,€que€dans€lð ðun€et€lð ðautre€cas,€un€d tenteur€l gitime€peutÐ ‡ Ö Ðconsid rer€la€lettre€de€change€comme€payable€au€porteur.Ý ƒ ÿÿÝ8 l9 ݌Рm ¼ ÐŒÓ Ø ÓÓ ÓÓ $ ° œX ‰ ‰ ‰ ŒX $ ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ & ÿÿÿ ÝÔ S ¦ õ S ¢ ÔÓ S ÓÓ ÓÓ € ÓÝ ÝÝ ‚ & ÿÿÿÆ ÝÝ ÝSelon€moi,€ce€passage€exprime€avec€exactitude€le€sens€de€la€jurisprudence€applicable€et€jeÐ ¦ õ Ðsuis€dð ðaccord€avec€la€Cour€dð ðappel€quð ð tant€donn €la€conclusion€dð ðintention€frauduleuse€de€laÐ ÿ N Ðpart€de€Chan€lorsquð ðil€a€tir €lð ðeffet€en€cause,€la€preneuse€de€celui„ci€est€une€personne€fictiveÐ X § Ðau€sens€de€la€jurisprudence€(voir€aussi€le€troisi me€exemple€cit €dans€lð ðouvrage€deÐ ± ÐFalconbridge,€ò òBanking€and€Bills€of€Exchange,€ó ó7ò òò òeó óó ó€ d.,€1969,€ €la€p.€486),€et€que€la€banque€ taitÐ Y Ðdonc€en€droit€de€consid rer€le€ch que€comme€payable€au€porteur€et,€en€cons quence,€deÐ c ² Ðd biter€le€compte€de€lð ðappelante€du€montant€y€figurant.Ý ƒ & ÿÿÆ J= ÝŒÐ
|