|
€At€the€same€time,€it€oftenÐ Ä ' Ðrequires€that€the€counsellor€keep€records€of€what€has€transpired€during€her€sessions€withÐ \ ø Ðthe€plaintiff.€A€plaintiff€may€also€maintain€a€private€diary€of€these€experiences,€thoughts,Ð ô Ðand€feelings.Ô # † X s¸ X X X s¸HJ # ÔÔ ‡ X s¸ X X X s¸ ÔÝ ƒ % Ñý•I °I ݌РŒ ( ÐŒÝ ÝÌÝ ‚ % Ñýÿ ÝÝ ÝÝ ‚ % ÑýÔO Ýà „ àÚ ƒ z Ú92Ú ÚÛ € z \ Ûà Ü àÝ Ýà œ àÔ # † X s¸ X X X s¸{O # ÔÔ ‡ X s¸ X X X s¸ ÔThus,€by€its€very€nature,€this€civil€wrong€creates€a€situation€where€a€writtenÐ ¼ X Ðrecord€will€be€made€of€the€most€intimate€details€of€the€plaintiffð ðs€life.€These€documentsÐ T ð Ðmay€also€provide€a€unique€record€of€the€injury€which€was€allegedly€caused.€At€the€sameÐ ì ˆ Ðtime,€as€Ô_ ÔMcLachlinÔ_ Ô€J.€observes,€much€of€such€information€in€the€records€will€be€of€veryÐ „ Ðlimited€value€to€the€trial€process.€The€same€can€be€said€of€any€private€record€of€theÐ ¸ Ðplaintiffð ðs€thoughts,€feelings,€and€experiences€regarding€€the€assault.€Given€this€context,Ð ´ P Ðthe€traditional€approach€to€discovery,€the€one€where€the€plaintiff€must€rely€upon€the€ò òadÐ L è Ðhoc€ó óprotection€privilege€provides,€will€serve€as€a€strong€disincentive€to€plaintiffs€toÐ ä € Ðattempt€to€recover€compensation€for€the€injury€caused.€The€mutual€exchange€ofÐ |! " Ðinformation€for€the€shared€purpose€of€expediting€the€search€for€justice€is€turned€into€aÐ #° $ Ðprocess€which€may€prevent€a€plaintiff€from€seeking€compensation€in€the€courts€or€mayÐ ¬$H & Ðencourage€a€premature€and€unfair€settlement€to€avoid€excessive€disclosure€of€the€privateÐ D&à ( Ðdocuments.€Such€a€result€cannot€comport€with€our€sense€of€justice,€particularly€as€it€isÐ Ü'x!* Ðinformed€by€the€ò òCharteró ó€values€of€privacy€and€equality.€Clearly,€a€more€predictableÐ t) #, Ðprocedure€is€in€order,€one€which€addresses€the€unique€difficulties€faced€by€plaintiffs€inÐ +¨$.
|
|
Ðmati re€civile.€€La€partie€qui€demande€la€production€doit€en€informer€les€personnes€ayantÐ Ô/p)4 Ðint r t€ €ce€que€les€dossiers€demeurent€confidentiels.€€Pour€quð ðun€tribunal€puisseÐ d Ðordonner€la€communication€pr alable€de€dossiers€priv s€ €la€d fense,€il€doit€tout€dð ðabordÐ ü ˜ Ðd terminer€quels€documents€ont€une€pertinence€probable€relativement€ €une€question€enÐ ” 0 Ðlitige.€€Pour€sð ðacquitter€de€cette€t che,€le€tribunal€doit€disposer€des€renseignementsÐ , È Ðn cessaires.€€En€mati re€civile,€les€renseignements€n cessaires€sont€fournis€au€moyen€deÐ Ä ` Ðlð ðaffidavit€dans€lequel€la€partie€qui€demande€lð ðordonnance€expose€les€raisons€pourÐ \ ø Ðlesquelles€la€production€des€documents€en€question€est€requise.€€Le€tribunal€doit€ensuiteÐ ô Ðordonner€que€les€documents€ayant€une€pertinence€probable€lui€soient€remis€pour€quð ðilÐ Œ ( Ðpuisse€les€examiner€et€y€supprimer€tout€renseignement€qui,€selon€lui,€nð ða€aucuneÐ $ À Ðpertinence€probable€ou€doit€par€ailleurs€ chapper€ €la€production€apr s€pond ration€desÐ ¼ X Ðdroits€en€cause.Ý ƒ y 3£BÑ oÑ ÝŒÐ T ð Ü Ð Ü Ð ÐŒÝ ÝÌà „ àÝ " ‚ y 3£ / " ÝÝ ÝÝ ‚ y 3£ Ø ÝÔ2 # ÔÚ Ú48Ú Ú.Ô3 Ôà0 Ü àÝ Ýà œ àà ø àDans€cette€d marche,€les€facteurs€ nonc s€par€notre€Cour€relativementÐ „ Ð €des€poursuites€criminelles€sð ðappliquent€ galement,€sous€r serve€des€l g resÐ ¸ Ðmodifications€qui€sð ðimposent€pour€satisfaire€aux€exigences€des€poursuites€civiles.€€LeÐ ´ P Ðtribunal€devrait€tenir€compte€des€consid rations€suivantes:€€la€n cessit €du€dossier€pourÐ L è Ðassurer€la€tenue€dð ðun€proc s€ quitable,€la€valeur€probante€du€dossier,€la€nature€et€la€port eÐ ä € Ðdes€attentes€raisonnables€en€mati re€de€confidentialit €du€dossier,€la€question€de€savoirÐ |! " Ðsi€la€production€du€dossier€reposerait€sur€une€croyance€discriminatoire,€et€le€pr judice€queÐ #° $ Ðla€divulgation€pourrait€causer€ €la€dignit ,€ €la€vie€priv e€et€ €la€s curit €de€la€personneÐ ¬$H & Ðde€la€partie€demanderesse.€€Il€faut€ galement€prendre€en€consid ration€les€facteursÐ D&à ( Ðsuppl mentaires€que€repr sentent€lð ðavantage€que€les€deux€parties€pourrontÐ Ü'x!* Ð ventuellement€tirer€dð ðune€proc dure€ quitable€de€communication€pr alable€desÐ t) #, Ðdocuments,€le€choix€quð ða€la€partie€demanderesse€dð ðengager€ou€non€des€poursuites€civilesÐ +¨$. Ðet€lð ðeffet€dissuasif€que€cette€proc dure€risque€dð ðavoir€sur€la€partie€demanderesse€dans€desÐ ¤,@&0 Ðpoursuites€civiles€relatives€ €une€agression€sexuelle.Ý ƒ y 3£ Ø BØ ÝŒÐ
|